Jump to content

hoodie axel

Banned
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2,395

  • Joined

 Content Type 

Everything posted by hoodie axel

  1. hoodie axel
    You'd give Nathan's Olympic outings anything more than a 5 for PE? You're indeed generous.
  2. hoodie axel
    Hahaha yeah, true, true. It will be very interesting to see how everyone scores. Maybe I'll involve myself, too, just to give unpopular opinions. The discussion would indeed be very nice to see.
  3. hoodie axel
    There shouldn't be a rule for scoring down, but I just want the objectivity to be there. I don't think Patrick Chan's strength was his IN in a few SPs, but I can't say that other judges wouldn't mark highly when judging a clean performance.
  4. hoodie axel
    I think this is a good idea, but going back to Sochi (and again I don't know what you want to rescore here), I think TP for Spin and StSq levels is a good idea, because I think Yuna's StSq levels were called incorrectly. At least in the LP. But what standard of judging? IN and PE are at least a little subjective. Going to Patrick Chan's SP in CoC 2016, would we have someone give him anything more than a 6 for IN and PE? OTOH, a skater having a meltdown doesn't necessarily have to be performing too badly, like Boyang in his SA 2016 SP, who would be getting a 7 for PE there from me. Would the judges necessarily evaluate everything properly without standards for PCS? For instance, I don't think Seimei's CO in 2018 was a 10 (close to 9), but is there a standard there?
  5. hoodie axel
    BTW, how would the rescoring work? I have tried to score the SPs of a few favourite skaters in the way BoP scores programs and have felt satisfied with the results. I've also tried to score SPs in the way the judges do and have felt my IQ slowly dropping.
  6. hoodie axel
    Sorry if this is grave digging, but have they managed to fix these issues? I don't think so with Shoma. @Fresca@meoima
  7. hoodie axel
    There is a comparison of SS between Patrick Chan and Yuzuru Hanyu here: http://the-real-xmonster.tumblr.com/post/165539440729/i-have-heard-people-say-that-yuzurus-and However, I haven't really found anything I would call an unbiased comparison between the SS of Boyang, Nathan, and Shoma. I know there exists a disparity between them, and I know they each have their own strengths in other sections of PCS (Boyang has generally better PE; Shoma is generally better at IN), but I want to know how to compare them. I also want to know what facets factor in: Is posture something that affects SS? In general, how do you determine who has good SS, when it's not extremely obvious like with Carolina Kostner?
  8. hoodie axel
    Good luck
×
×
  • Create New...