I'm going to try it once, and see how it treats me... and if it takes too long to type it up, will just evaluate the rest and post totals I don't think all the camera angles and video quality are coming together perfectly for me, so there might be some leeway on UR calls, and I did go by messy edges on footwork to knock a level down if it seemed good.
(element; GOE/PCS; reason; element score)
ALINA ZAGITOVA Worlds 2019
3Lz+3Lo +1 Not a big lutz, but the jumps are clean, and she did do steps out of the element. Barely rotated +3Lo though. 10.80
FCSp4 +2 Transitions with little set up into this, but the camel position takes time to settle correct properly and still isn't great; her donut and catchfoot are just OK. Nice build with the music though. 3.84
StSq4 +3 Some nice choreographic touches and nice expression at points, but not always the best edge quality. 5.07
2A +3 The jump isn't that big, but nice transition into it, and she does hold the exit edge well here. 4.29
LSp4 +2 Her sideways position is weak but they disguise it nice with her hands behind her back; her haircutter is weak too, but they introduce the hand position there; the Biellmann could be better. Nice musicality though. 3.24
3F (x) +1 Nice overall element with Rippon right on the music, but it's not a great jump. 6.36
FCCoSp4 +2 Nice entry, but several weak positions here, and goes only "OK" with the music. 4.20
SS: 8.00 She showed some nice qualities here, looked less laboured, and did OK with edging, speed, and control. Too much of flinging herself around to get the correct turn, though.
TR: 8.50 Some hard ones, and they thankfully highlighted the music with simple edge-holding at points, but not always done with the best quality.
PE: 8.25 Presents herself well here, but comes off too child-like at points where such a quality shouldn't have been present.
CO: 7.25 I like the element placements on a superficial level, but the choreography could use more interesting movement. Grander movements to the music (like the charlotte) are nice, but the footwork appears too athletic for that section of the music, nor are the spins well choreographed. There isn't enough dimensionality or cohesion to this piece, and her poor form detracts, too.
IN: 6.75 I don't think the music cuts were the end of the world. They weren't used very well though. There yet again isn't enough cohesion in this interpretation: for instance while people severely disliked the smashing glass effect, I think had the piece been presented as a woman going slowly mad, and had someone who had better form and performance ability than Zagitova skated to this, with choreography becoming slowly more haphazard, it could have been better. Moreover, the spins are a weak point too: The final spin isn't grand enough, and the flying camel isn't foreboding enough.
Total score: 38.39 + 31.00 = 69.39
2A +1 Good entry, but wild on the exit and the axis. 3.63
3Lz+3T +1 Rippon Lutz, and OK 3T with a clean landing, but barely rotated. 3T looked UR in real time, but looks like she made it on rewatch. 10.69
3S< 0 Her salchow is simply not good. 3.23
2A +1 Nice entry, but not great at all. The exit edge is too uncontrolled, but she did a kick I guess. 3.63
FCSp4 +2 Same criticism as in SP. 3.84
ChSq +1 Not great positions or performance, but alright ice coverage. 3.50
3Lz<+3Lo< (x) -1 Has to struggle on the landing of the 3Lo 8.48
3F+2T<+2Lo< (x) 0 Wonky landing, but the arm variations make me give it 0. 7.79
3F (x) 0 Wonky landing, but again arm variation and some transitions leading in. Looked UR in real time, but video quality not great to confirm. 5.83
CCoSp4 +1 Weak-ish positions, and not done with great speed either. 3.85
StSq3 0 Several laboured turns, and looked like she botched some. 3.30
FCCoSp4 +1 Her positions and speed were simply worse here to me than in the SP. 3.85
SS: 7.50 Far more of a struggle here than the SP.
TR: 8.00 Some difficult ones, but struggle on landings, and poor edge quality in general detracts. Her flow is too poor to aid this score further.
PE: 7.50 Her body awareness and expression is not great in this performance.
CO: 6.75 The choreography isn't good. I don't think the layout is doing a bad job of telling a story, the long setup into the lutz-loop adds intrigue for sure, and I get the idea of the initial movement for instance, but her constant changes of bodyline detract with the music and highlight poor form.
IN: 7.00 Slightly higher simply because an actual attempt at a story is here, but some things simply don't work with the music. Simply holding the edge out of jumps to establish mood and character would have been remarkable.
Total Score: 62.15 + 59.60 = 121.75