Comparing SS

[hoodie axel]

There is a comparison of SS between Patrick Chan and Yuzuru Hanyu here: http://the-real-xmonster.tumblr.com/post/165539440729/i-have-heard-people-say-that-yuzurus-and

 

However, I haven't really found anything I would call an unbiased comparison between the SS of Boyang, Nathan, and Shoma. I know there exists a disparity between them, and I know they each have their own strengths in other sections of PCS (Boyang has generally better PE; Shoma is generally better at IN), but I want to know how to compare them. I also want to know what facets factor in: Is posture something that affects SS? In general, how do you determine who has good SS, when it's not extremely obvious like with Carolina Kostner?

[meoima]

On 4/5/2018 at 12:13 PM, hoodie axel said:

There is a comparison of SS between Patrick Chan and Yuzuru Hanyu here: http://the-real-xmonster.tumblr.com/post/165539440729/i-have-heard-people-say-that-yuzurus-and

 

However, I haven't really found anything I would call an unbiased comparison between the SS of Boyang, Nathan, and Shoma. I know there exists a disparity between them, and I know they each have their own strengths in other sections of PCS (Boyang has generally better PE; Shoma is generally better at IN), but I want to know how to compare them. I also want to know what facets factor in: Is posture something that affects SS? In general, how do you determine who has good SS, when it's not extremely obvious like with Carolina Kostner?

You can read more on this matter here: https://curiouscat.me/chiburahakkai/post/578487224?1532175326